Although I’ve been collecting insects since I was a kid (and seriously for nearly three decades), it has only been in more recent years that fall has become an important part of the collecting season for me. With the notable exception of Fall 1978, when the Systematic Entomology course I was enrolled in sent me on a frantic quest to become one of the few undergraduate members of the exclusive “200 family” club (I got 205!), I long viewed fall as a time to hang up the net and begin the winter-long process of mounting, labeling, and curating the hundreds – sometimes thousands – of specimens I had collected earlier in the year during spring and summer. This has primarily been a reflection of my taxonomic interest – woodboring beetles in the families Buprestidae and Cerambycidae, which occur at their overwhelmingly greatest abundance and diversity throughout most of North America during spring and summer but are found only sparingly later in the season. Tiger beetles (family Cicindelidae) changed all that, and when I first began serious study of the group around 10 years ago, I found the combination of gorgeous weather and multitude of “spring/fall” species that emerge briefly during fall an irresistible siren call to the field. I’ve not looked back, and the Annual Fall Tiger Beetle Collecting Trip™ is now an established and eagerly anticipated event.No species embodies all that I love about fall tiger beetle collecting more than Cicindela obsoleta vulturina, the prairie tiger beetle. I first learned of the occurrence in Missouri of this large, dark green species back in 2000, when I saw a single specimen in the Enns Entomology Museum collected in Protem, Taney Co. I was just beginning my tiger beetle studies and would later learn what the Tiger Beetle Guild already knew – that the occurrence of this species in Missouri was restricted to cedar glade habitats in the White River Hills region in the extreme southwestern part of the state, and that the population occurring there and in adjacent northern Arkansas was disjunct by 300+ miles from the main population in Texas and Oklahoma. I couldn’t wait to see it for myself and eventually enlisted the help of Eric Eaton, living in the area at the time, and asked him to let me know if he saw a large green tiger beetle after the late summer rains began. That September, I got a message from Eric saying that he had seen just such a beast not far from his home, and the following weekend he and I would enjoy the chance to meet each other in person and the splendor of the season while finding this marvelous species at several locations in the area. Thus began my love affair with this species, and for several years I returned to the area each fall to document additional localities for this and other tiger beetle species occurring in the area. In fact, until a few weeks ago it had been several years since I had last seen this species in the field. I did make an attempt to see it again last year but returned home from that early October trip unsuccessful, cold and wet. Thus, when tiger beetle enthusiast Steve Spomer mentioned to me earlier this summer that he wanted to see our Missouri population, I jumped at the chance to coordinate our visits this fall and show him some of my favorite sites. The Patron Saint of Cicindela was smiling down upon us that day, as perfect timing and sunny skies combined to bring adults out in an abundance that I’d not seen in any of my previous visits. I would take advantage of this rare opportunity and spend the next day in the area as well, documenting a number of new localities along the northern and eastern edge of its known distribution, including a far eastern extension of its range to Caney Mountain Conservation Area in Ozark Co. where we had long suspected the beetle to occur but failed in all previous attempts to find it. The prairie tiger beetle is the easternmost subspecies of the large grassland tiger beetle, which along with its other included subspecies covers a geographic range covering most of Texas, New Mexico, and eastern Arizona and extending up through western Oklahoma and Kansas into eastern Colorado. Individuals of subspecies vulturina, occurring primarily in eastern/central Texas, are distinguished from the other subspecies (nominate in western Texas and eastern New Mexico north into Colorado, santaclarae in New Mexico and Arizona, and neojuvenilis in south Texas) by their generally black to olive-green coloration and reduced, narrow elytral markings, typically with an inverted “V” at mid-elytron. The Missouri/Arkansas disjunct population is interesting from several standpoints:
- Individuals mostly dark olive-green – no black individuals.
- Elytral maculations more completely developed.
- Adults active in late summer/early fall rather than summer.
These features, in particular coloration and maculation, have fueled speculation that this isolated population might be subspecifically distinct (Pearson et al. 2006). A recent review of material from throughout its range found these color characters of limited use in unequivocally diagnosing individuals from the Missouri and Arkansas population as a separate subspecific taxon (Mawdsley 2009); however, a molecular systematics approach ultimately may be needed to resolve the status of this population. Presumably, the Missouri/Arkansas disjunct population represents a hypsithermal relict, left behind when the return of cooler, moister conditions caused a retreat of the formerly more expansive grasslands to their current position. If true, then the Missouri/Arkansas population has been isolated from the parent population for ~6,000 years. I suspect that the late summer/early fall adult phenology is an adaptation to local precipitation patterns, relying on more predictable late summer rains to trigger adult emergence after the generally droughty months of July and August. In this regard it differs fundamentally from the true “fall” species, which emerge briefly in the fall as sexually immature adults before overwintering and re-emerging in the spring for mating and oviposition. These Missouri/Arkansas disjuncts do not re-emerge in spring, but instead mate and lay eggs in the fall before the onset of cold weather. The eggs hatch as well (based on my growth chamber observations of this species), so winter also is passed as a larva – either as newly-hatched 1st instars, or as later instars that hatched during the previous year(s) – rather than as adults.
I have noted considerable variation in the coloration and maculations of individuals in this population. The individual in the first photograph above is typical of the population – dark olive-green with thin but nearly complete maculations. That individual comes from Blackjack Knob (Taney Co.), which is near the heart of the White River Hills region. However, the degree to which the maculations are developed is variable, ranging from rather incomplete to even more fully developed due to the presence of a marginal connection. Additionally, a few individuals can be found that show greater or lesser suffusion of brown on the head, pronotum, and elytra. At another location in the county closer to the northern distributional limit (Hwy 160/Cane Creek Rd.), this brown suffusion is more common and variably expressed from minimal to nearly complete. The photographs below show five individuals from this site expressing differing degrees of brown as well as the variable macular development seen throughout the population:
There is another site even further north in the county (Merriam Woods), which I found for the first time on this trip and, to my knowledge, represents the northernmost extent of the population in Missouri. At this site, nearly all of the individuals show coppery-brown coloration with almost no hint of green. These fully brown individuals seem to represent an appearance that is completely unlike that seen in any other part of the range of the species. The individual in the photo below typifies the appearance of the beetles seen at this site: I’m less familiar with coloration of the population further south in Arkansas, although in my limited collecting in that area I recall that most individuals I encountered exhibited the dark olive-green coloration typical of individuals at Blackjack Knob and other more southern sites in Missouri. Thus, there seems to a clinal element to variability in coloration in the Missouri/Arkansas disjunct population. I suspect that the unique coloration of the beetles in this population is related to the soils with which they are associated. Light gray Jefferson City-Cotter dolomite bedrock forms the core of the White River Hills landscape and is exposed extensively in the glades that dominate its knobs and slopes. These exposures are weather-stained black and overlain by thin, black soils that support dark, green-black lichens amongst the sparse vegetation, as seen in the following photographs taken at the newly identified northeasternmost site at Caney Mountain Conservation Area:
The glades and dolomite exposures where these beetles are found in the White River Hills and the dry oak woodlands that surround them have a characteristic look that is not seen once one leaves the area, and I have found many new sites for the beetle in the northern and eastern fringes of the region by stopping at locations where the roadside exposures had the right “look.” The variation in maculation and coloration seen in this population may be an indication that the population is still adapting to local conditions since becoming isolated from main population.
Currently, I have 3rd-instar larvae that I collected from their burrows at Blackjack Knob (adults mostly green) and Merriam Woods (adults mostly brown) and hope the rear them to adulthood next year. If I succeed in getting virgin adults from the two sites, I think it would be interesting to do some single-pair crossings and rear the progeny to see how coloration is expressed. A long term project, for sure, as these beetles probably require at least two seasons to reach adulthood, but rearing them is fun! A more difficult, yet far more interesting, project would be to secure virgin adults from the mostly black main population in Texas – or even the bright green, thickly-maculated santaclarae subspecies from Arizona – to see how interbreeding them with these Missouri disjuncts would affect coloration and maculation in their progeny – they could be some of the most unusual appearing large grassland tiger beetles ever seen (not to mention their tongue-twisting taxonomic moniker of Cicindela (Cicindelidia) obsoleta vulturina [Missouri disjunct] x obsoleta santaclarae!). Timing would be a difficulty, since the Texas and Arizona populations exhibit a more normal summer adult phenology, but it would be worth a try if I could secure a source of larvae for rearing. Anybody?
Photo Details (insects): Canon 50D w/ 100mm macro lens (ISO 100, 1/250 sec, f/13-22), Canon MT-24EX flash (1/4-1/2 ratio) w/ Sto-Fen + GFPuffer diffusers. Typical post-processing (levels, minor cropping, unsharp mask).
Mawdsley, J. R. 2009. Geographic variation in U. S. populations of the tiger beetle Cicindela obsoleta Say (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae). Insecta Mundi 0094:1–10.
Pearson, D. L., C. B. Knisley and C. J. Kazilek. 2006. A Field Guide to the Tiger Beetles of the United States and Canada. Oxford University Press, New York, 227 pp.
Copyright © Ted C. MacRae 2010
18 thoughts on “Missouri’s disjunct population of Cicindela obsoleta vulturina”
These pictures put the cool in Cooleoptera.
“Cooleoptera” – I love it!
Can’t help out with the larvae, but it sounds like you have quite an experiment planned. What kind of space does it take for you to house your collection? And to keep your live specimens, larvae, etc. ? Do you need an indoor space to control temp, moisture, etc?
I am glad that you showed how varied the individuals can be for this species. Its one thing to read it in a guide book, quite another to see so many examples. Thanks, Ted!
It takes lots and lots of space 😀
The collection is housed in 111 Cornell glass-topped drawers (18x16x2.5 inches) stored in vertical metal cabinets plus ~40 smaller wooden Schmidt boxes lined up on shelves. The rearing takes place in various-sized containers on a cart in a growth chamber at work. I’m fortunate to have space for the rearing, as light, heat and humidity are all controlled for optimal plant growth – all I have to do is add prey items and water 1-2 times per week.
Frankly, I took pictures of so many individuals because I was just trying to make sure I had some good shots. I was quite amazed at the diversity of coloration and maculation that I had captured when I examined the photos later and decided to make that a focus of the blog entry. Glad you appreciated it.
That is a lot of variation in one species…no wonder I can’t always match up with the illustrations in the field guide!
It’s unusual to find this much variation within a single population – usually the variation is across the range and shows some geographical correlation. It suggests to me that the population is still actively adapting to conditions in this particular region.
You are spot on with your recollection about the Arkansas population – dark olive-green. Just pulled out specimens I collected in 2008 from dolomite glades in and around the Ozark National Forest in Stone County, Arkansas to compare to your photos. Very similar to your Blackjack Knob shot. Ozark Mountain glades are cool places.
Thanks for confirming this Michael. I sneaked down into Arkansas south of Bull Shoals Lake (Boone Co.) on that 2000 trip and found them at a couple of sites. I presume yours come from the vicinity of Calico Rock? I haven’t seen that population yet but will probably look for it next year for inclusion in population studies.
Yep, around Calico Rock is a good spot. There is also a nice glade complex just east of Optimus (south of Calico Rock) – a little harder to get to but better “buffered” from human impact than the Calico Rock glades. I can provide the coordinates next time you plan on heading south into Arkansas.
Excellent – I’ll be in touch!
As you have stated, that is an amazing amount of variation in a single population. I have seen the variation across the range for C. obsoleta santaclarae in Arizona and New Mexico from nice green ones in AZ to black individuals in New Mexico. Can’t say that I have ever looked for larvae though, only the adults.
Your work on the tiger beetles in Missouri and the Great Plains is fascinating and much needed. Keep up the great work!
Thank you, Charlie! I sure would like to get out there and look for the nominate and santaclarae versions of this species. I found the larval burrows in a spot where I had seen the adults abundant and deduced this species is what they must have been because of their size – almost as large as Tetracha virginica but lacking the white-bordered pronotum. No other tiger beetle in Missouri is near as large.
Glades are amazing places, especially because many of the plants and animals seem to have been dropped in from the desert southwest. I’m glad you mentioned the little-known patron saint Ted. I graduated from Saint Vulturina Grade School.
I don’t think any natural community in Missouri enamors me more than glades. Igneous, dolomite, or sandstone – I’ve searched out many of them and hope to visit every significant glade that exists in the state before my time is done.
St. Vulturina, huh? Funny.
Pingback: Bumelia borer on white « Beetles In The Bush
Pingback: Two things I love about glades during fall… « Beetles In The Bush
Pingback: Dromochorus pruinina is not extirpated in Missouri… yet! « Beetles In The Bush
Pingback: Dromochorus pruinina is not extirpated in Missouri… yet! | Beetles In The Bush